Finding a decent buffet in Selden, NY can feel like a lottery—except here, your odds are much better. If you know where to look, Selden offers a surprising variety of buffets, from family-friendly classics to hidden perks tucked in strip plazas. Local buffets cater to busy families, picky eaters, and big appetites. Whether you’re craving familiar comfort favorites or searching for something a bit more adventurous, there’s a spot with just the right mix ready for you.
I’ve tasted my way through Selden’s buffet scene—from steamy platters of freshly prepared stir-fry to crisp salads and sparkling platters designed for sharing, each place offers its own atmosphere and specialties. If you want to dodge the guesswork and go straight to the best spreads in town, you’re in the right place. What follows is a local’s eye view of Selden’s top buffets: the real standouts, the unsung heroes, and more than a few return-worthy plates.
Where to find the best buffets in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Selden, NY:
- Old Country Buffet
- Buffet Express
- Empire Buffet
- Bhr Corp
- Good Taste Buffet
- Sunny Buffet
- Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
- Creole Buffet
- Teppanyaki & Supreme Buffet
- East West Buffet
1. Old Country Buffet
Tucked along Nesconset Highway, Old Country Buffet draws in families and loyal regulars, all looking to pile their plates without hassle. The dining room has a friendly, no-pretense feel that makes big groups and solo visitors feel equally at ease.
What truly sets this spot apart is the solid rotation of comfort food classics. Think of fluffy mashed potatoes, crisp vegetable medleys, and satisfying pasta dishes. For me, the baked ziti—oozing with cheese yet not greasy—stands out every time.
You’ll want to scoop up their salads and roasted options too. Old Country Buffet makes simple food shine, avoiding culinary frills. It’s the go-to when you crave filling plates, quick service, and reliable flavors, all rooted in straightforward home cooking.
2. Buffet Express
(631) 981-8243Call
Buffet Express sits quietly in Ronkonkoma, easy to miss unless you know what you’re looking for. Step inside and you’ll find a no-fuss setup with the focus clearly on food. During my last visit, the bustle around the fresh stir-fry station made it obvious—this place draws a crowd for its hot, made-to-order selections.
What separates Buffet Express from other spots is how quickly everything moves, yet the dishes are still flavor-packed. Try the steamed dumplings and mixed vegetable lo mein. Both are crowd-pleasers and offer a taste of the balanced, home-style cooking that’s their hallmark.
The buffet line is tidy and well-stocked, perfect when you want variety without feeling lost in choices. For those who crave something quick, delicious, and never generic, Buffet Express delivers.
3. Empire Buffet
(631) 874-4200Call
Empire Buffet anchors Main Street in Center Moriches with its dependable variety and spacious layout. The parking is easy and free, so you can show up hungry and stress-free. I’ve spent a few evenings here with friends, gathered around big round tables sampling a bit of everything.
Empire Buffet’s draw is its generous spread and constantly refreshed selections. The vegetable lo mein is silky and satisfying, while the sautéed green beans pack real crunch. Their sesame tofu, perfectly crisp outside yet soft inside, shouldn’t be missed.
If you enjoy buffets that give you options without compromising freshness, this place will keep you coming back. It’s a solid pick when you want a meal that’s as laid-back as it is plentiful.
4. Bhr Corp
(631) 543-9583Call
Bhr Corp sits conveniently on Jericho Turnpike, a spot I first wandered into on a rainy evening with zero expectations. The place delivers just what you hope for in a buffet—ample selections and brisk service. The vibe is relaxed, making it easy for small groups or casual dinners.
What sets Bhr Corp apart is the steady quality of its hot dishes. I always go for the cooked-to-perfection vegetable stir-fry and pillowy white rice. The buffet line stays well supplied, even when the rush is on.
Bhr Corp is great for those times you want classic, straightforward fare without any drama. Their approach is simple: tasty food, easy atmosphere, and just enough variety to keep things interesting.
5. Good Taste Buffet
(631) 543-9583Call
Tucked into the Mayfair Shopping Center, Good Taste Buffet is exactly what its name promises. It’s one of those spots that feels welcoming every time you walk in. For me, it’s the place I hit when I want variety and value minus the crowds.
Despite the below-average price, the quality never takes a hit. The sautéed broccoli and vegetable fried rice always taste fresh, and there’s a steady stream of hot, tender noodles. The line is clean, items are well labeled, and staff are attentive without hovering.
Order up a plate of their mixed vegetable stir-fry—it’s crisp, colorful, and flavorful thanks to light seasoning. For anyone seeking easy comfort food and budget-friendly buffets, Good Taste Buffet is a standout in Commack.
6. Sunny Buffet
(631) 665-6050Call
Sunny Buffet lights up East Main Street with its lively energy and budget-friendly options. I wandered in on a chilly day and found the bright, bustling space instantly inviting. Free parking and wheelchair accessibility make it an easy stop for everyone.
The buffet isn’t the largest in Bay Shore, but it makes up for it with well-executed staples. Their stir-fried string beans and egg drop soup always earn a spot on my first plate. Crisp vegetables and consistent flavors show the kitchen pays attention.
Try a plate of their steamed broccoli and tofu in light sauce—simple, healthy fare that never disappoints. Sunny Buffet is proof you don’t need extravagance to have a great meal out.
7. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
(631) 620-3688Call
Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc in West Babylon brings a lively twist to the standard buffet experience. The vibe is casual, but you notice right away how often the steam tables are refilled. Freshness and selection are obvious priorities here. I’ve brought family here more than once when we couldn’t agree on what to eat—there’s enough variety for everyone to leave happy.
The hibachi grill is a highlight. Grab a plate, pick your vegetables, and watch as your custom order gets sizzled up right in front of you. It’s simple, interactive, and always delivers on flavor.
The sauteed bok choy and fried rice are always on my list, both perfectly executed. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc stands out for letting you tailor your meal without ever rushing the experience.
8. Creole Buffet
(516) 489-3542Call
Creole Buffet on Uniondale Avenue offers a break from the ordinary, bringing lively flavors to the Selden buffet scene. The atmosphere is cozy and unpretentious, yet the food is anything but bland. Every visit feels like a small celebration of comfort cooking.
I was drawn in by the aroma alone and kept coming back for their red beans and rice, plus the vibrant sautéed greens. The kitchen takes pride in delivering soul-satisfying dishes that are full of character.
Order up their veggie jambalaya for a taste of something unique—zesty, filling, and just the right amount of heat. For diners seeking bold flavors and true variety, Creole Buffet is worth the drive.
9. Teppanyaki & Supreme Buffet
(203) 908-3700Call
Teppanyaki & Supreme Buffet on Huntington Road is worth a bit of travel for anyone who prizes variety with their buffet experience. The open grill always catches my attention—watching chefs at work never gets old. There’s a blend of interactive dining and classic buffet comfort that keeps regulars coming back.
On my last visit, I loaded up on vegetable fried rice and sautéed mushrooms straight from the teppanyaki station. The fresh, customizable plates set this spot apart from the predictable buffet format.
Make room for their assorted vegetable sushi and crispy green beans. If you’re after customizable meals and a lively atmosphere, Teppanyaki & Supreme Buffet checks every box.
10. East West Buffet
(516) 579-3388Call
East West Buffet in Levittown strikes a balance between classic Asian cuisine and a few surprises from the Western side. The setting is welcoming, and the buffet layout invites exploration. My first visit, I ended up with a plate that covered nearly every continent—no regrets.
What makes East West Buffet stand out is the care put into each section. The vegetable fried rice is fluffy and never oily, while their assorted stir-fried greens bring out a punch of flavor you rarely find at buffets.
For something different, try their steamed dumplings or lightly seasoned vegetable tempura. East West Buffet is perfect if you want to mix traditions without compromising freshness or taste.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best buffets in Selden, NY?
The most popular buffets in and near Selden include Old Country Buffet, Buffet Express, Empire Buffet, and Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc. Each offers a broad range of classic and specialty dishes with something for everyone.
Do buffets in Selden offer vegetarian options?
Yes, most buffets have a solid selection of vegetarian-friendly fare, like stir-fried veggies, fresh salads, steamed rice, and tofu dishes.
Are most buffets in Selden kid-friendly?
Yes, almost all buffets here cater to families. Many have kid-friendly menus and casual atmospheres that make dining with little ones easy.
Can you find international cuisine at Selden buffets?
Definitely. Buffets like East West Buffet and Teppanyaki & Supreme Buffet offer a mix of Asian and Western dishes, and Creole Buffet brings its own unique regional flavors.
Do I need a reservation for local buffets?
Most buffets in Selden are walk-in friendly. But for larger groups, calling ahead can help secure seating without the wait.
