Buffets are a little like treasure hunts. You never quite know what you’ll discover, but the reward is a spread that promises variety and satisfaction for everyone at the table. Having spent more time at buffets than I’d care to confess, I’ve learned the secret signs of a truly great spot: warm rice, fresh bread, food steaming in their trays, and a room that always smells inviting but never overwhelming. Scouting New City, NY for the best buffets has been a delicious assignment, and I’ve collected more napkin notes and tip-offs from locals than any sane person probably should.
This guide is built on real visits, honest reviews, and a goal to help you find your next favorite plate. Whether you’re craving classic comfort food, something with a spicy twist, or dishes from across continents, you’ll find options here that stand out for quality and variety. If you appreciate generous portions and the freedom to try a bit of everything—without worrying about off-limits ingredients—stick with me. Your appetite will thank you.
Where to find the best buffets in New City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in New City, NY:
- La Familia A Plus Buffet
- Old Country Buffet
- Fancy Buffet Haitian Restaurant
- Latin Roots Buffet & Restaurant
- Aventura Buffet
- King Buffet Restaurant
- Fsa Cafeteria
- Poly Garden Inc
- Super Buffet
- 23 Buffet
1. La Familia A Plus Buffet
(845) 262-1160Call
La Familia A Plus Buffet feels like stumbling into a family gathering where everyone brings their best dish. Tables brim with hearty classics and endless sides—always fresh, never tired-looking. One visit hooked me on their crispy plantains and seasoned rice, a comfort duo I haven’t seen done better anywhere nearby.
Generous servings and steady service are the rule here, not the exception. If you want variety without guesswork, their rotating buffet trays never disappoint. Stick to the chicken stew or tangy vegetable medley for bold flavors rooted in tradition.
This spot stands out for authenticity and warmth, perfect for anyone who wants more than basic fare. The food here reflects a genuine love for sharing and celebrating the best recipes from home.
2. Old Country Buffet
(845) 371-4127Call
Old Country Buffet offers a dose of nostalgia where every plate brings you home, no matter where you started. Rows of comfort food greet you by the entrance, and I’ve spent more time than I’d admit deciding between their creamy mashed potatoes and buttery corn.
What sets this buffet apart is its home-style touch. The baked chicken is always juicy, with a golden skin that signals second helpings. If you crave classic American sides, their mac and cheese earns its place.
Solid portions and a bustling family vibe make it a favorite for regulars who want reliable, tasty food without pretense. Save room for the sweet potato pie—the slices vanish quickly for good reason.
3. Fancy Buffet Haitian Restaurant
Stepping into Fancy Buffet Haitian Restaurant is like stepping into the heart of Port-au-Prince, minus the airfare. The aroma of simmering spices fills the air, and each tray feels like a passport stamp from Haiti. On my first visit, I couldn’t skip the griot—crispy morsels of perfectly seasoned beef—paired with pikliz for a subtle kick.
This buffet stands out for authenticity and careful preparation. Each dish highlights the flavors and methods that define Haitian cuisine. The rice and beans here set the standard, while plantain fritters offer crunch and warmth in every bite.
If you want a taste of real Haitian cooking and friendly service, this spot delivers every time. Don’t miss the stews or the slow-cooked vegetable medley—their depth and richness reflect a true devotion to tradition.
4. Latin Roots Buffet & Restaurant
(845) 353-1234Call
Latin Roots Buffet & Restaurant quickly became a personal favorite for its genuine flavors and buzzing, family-friendly scene. Every buffet spread here brims with Latin classics done right. My first plate was a mountain of arroz con gandules and roasted vegetables, and I still dream about it.
This spot stands out for consistency. The chicken stew, always tender and savory, speaks to their kitchen’s dedication. Their selection of fresh salads and stewed beans rounds out the buffet for anyone craving wholesome, well-seasoned fare.
If you’re after real Latin comfort food in a relaxed setting, put this place on your must-try list. Finish with their yucca fries—they’re the crispy finale you didn’t know you needed.
5. Aventura Buffet
(845) 369-3161Call
Aventura Buffet has the easy-going charm of a neighborhood favorite where everyone can find something comforting. The buffet line is stocked with well-prepared staples—generous enough to satisfy anyone with a hearty appetite. My own go-to? Their green beans tossed with garlic and the roasted potatoes, both full of flavor and always hot.
What makes Aventura special is its mix of classic buffet favorites and a few surprises. The vegetable stir-fry and baked tilapia tend to stand out for their freshness and taste. There’s a steady crowd, but it never feels rushed or crowded.
If you’re looking for variety that delivers on taste, this spot does the job. Circle back for a second round of the seasoned rice—it won me over, and I doubt I’m the only one.
6. King Buffet Restaurant
(845) 368-0606Call
King Buffet Restaurant has a way of drawing you in with its expansive selection and dependable quality. Rows and rows of hot dishes make it tough to pick just one plate. I’m partial to their sautéed string beans and mixed vegetable stir-fry, both always vibrant and full of flavor.
This buffet stands out for its consistency and respectful service. The rice dishes, especially the fried rice, arrive at the table fluffy—not greasy—and pair well with everything from sautéed tofu to seasonal greens.
If you want a straightforward, crowd-pleasing buffet experience, King Buffet delivers every time. Don’t pass on their steamed dumplings; they never last long, and with good reason.
7. Fsa Cafeteria
Fsa Cafeteria is one of those hidden gems tucked inside SUNY Westchester Community College. The spread is designed for variety and speed, but the quality rarely takes a back seat. My first time here, I loaded my tray with roasted vegetables and perfectly cooked rice—filling and far better than your average campus fare.
What makes Fsa Cafeteria stand out is its focus on balance. Fresh salads, baked potatoes, and a rotating selection of wholesome hot dishes give busy diners real options. The lentil stew is particularly robust, and their soups never taste mass-produced.
If you want a reliable place with choices that suit every craving, this buffet holds up. Swing by during lunch hours for their hot entrees—you’ll see why students and staff keep coming back.
8. Poly Garden Inc
(914) 739-3913Call
Poly Garden Inc feels like a neighborhood standby with a buffet that covers all the bases. The spread is always fresh and offers vibrant colors and tempting aromas, making it hard to pick just one or two favorites. My top choice on each visit? Their vegetable lo mein and stir-fried broccoli, both consistently delicious and generously portioned.
The selection here shines for variety and careful preparation. Poly Garden’s steamed rice is never soggy, and the sautéed mushrooms deliver plenty of umami in every bite. If you like light, flavorful options, you’ll find the salads and tofu dishes live up to expectations.
For anyone chasing a comforting, reliable buffet experience without pretension, Poly Garden Inc stands out quietly but confidently. Don’t skip the egg drop soup—it’s the kind of warming dish you’ll want on repeat.
9. Super Buffet
(914) 422-3470Call
Super Buffet is the type of place where abundance meets convenience. The selection is massive, but everything feels well-considered and freshly prepared. The last time I visited, the vegetable fried rice and sautéed string beans won me over for their bright flavors and perfect textures.
This spot stands out for its ability to satisfy many tastes at once. The steamed broccoli and tofu dishes are a highlight, and the hot and sour soup always tastes like it’s made from scratch. There’s plenty of space and it never feels overcrowded, even at peak hours.
If you’re after variety and fast refills on your favorites, Super Buffet delivers without missing a beat. Make sure to circle back for seconds on the crispy noodles.
10. 23 Buffet
(973) 248-8228Call
23 Buffet makes it clear they’re serious about pleasing a crowd. The sheer range here, from Asian classics to seafood favorites, keeps diners coming back. On my last visit, the vegetable sushi rolls and sautéed mixed greens earned a permanent spot on my list of go-to plates.
What sets 23 Buffet apart is its attention to quality and friendly, efficient service. The steamed dumplings and fresh fruit selection are simple yet satisfying, always tasting like someone just put them out moments before you arrived.
If you want options for everyone—kids, picky eaters, and adventurous diners alike—this buffet delivers. Don’t pass up their stir-fried noodles; they have that elusive homemade flavor that’s rare in buffet settings.
More Things to Try in New City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated buffets in New City, NY?
Some of the most popular buffets include La Familia A Plus Buffet, Old Country Buffet, and Fancy Buffet Haitian Restaurant. Each offers a mix of unique flavors and consistent service.
Are there any buffets in New City, NY with vegetarian options?
Yes, almost every buffet on this list offers a variety of vegetarian dishes. Look for salad bars, vegetable stir-fries, and rice dishes at locations like King Buffet Restaurant and Poly Garden Inc.
Do buffets in New City, NY require reservations?
Most buffets are walk-in friendly, but some—like 23 Buffet—accept reservations for groups or special events. Calling ahead is a good idea on weekends or for larger parties.
Are there buffets with gluten-free options?
Several buffets accommodate gluten-free needs. You’ll find steamed vegetables, rice dishes, and fresh salads at many locations. It’s best to ask staff about specific ingredients if you have allergies.
Is parking available at most buffet restaurants?
Yes, free parking is usually available at most buffets mentioned here. Always double-check if you’re visiting for the first time or during busy hours.
Do any buffets in New City offer takeout?
Fancy Buffet Haitian Restaurant and others offer takeout options, so you can enjoy a buffet spread at home or on the go.
