Buffet hunting in Nutley, NJ, has defined a few of my most satisfying weekends. You know the feeling: stepping into a bustling dining room scented with garlic and roasted spices, and knowing you can try a little of everything. Nutley may be a small New Jersey town, but its buffet scene is anything but limited. From robust Brazilian spreads to Japanese spots with sushi rolls lined up like edible jewels, this town knows how to throw a generous feast—without worrying which dish to commit to.
I’ve sampled, sipped, and stacked plates across the area, always seeking out the freshest ingredients and the friendliest servers. This has taught me where the crowds gather for good reason, where dishes empty the fastest, and which spots cater to both the classics and something a bit more adventurous. If you want to avoid bland chains and skip anything that doesn’t meet halal standards, you’ll find this guide trims the list to the true highlights. Whether your heart beats for steaming dumplings, flame-kissed BBQ, or a spread of salads bigger than your appetite, you’ll want to keep reading.
Where to find the best buffets in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Nutley, NJ:
- HomeTown Buffet
- Family Buffet King
- Bnk Buffet & Company
- Dynasty Buffet
- Brazilian Buffet
- La Fiesta Buffet
- Tokyo Buffett
- S.Z. Cafe & Buffet
- Ichiban Grill & Buffet
1. HomeTown Buffet
(973) 667-4864Call
Step into HomeTown Buffet, and the first thing that hits you is the scent of fresh bread and slow-cooked comfort food. Nestled right on Washington Ave, this spot has long been the go-to for families who want to sample a bit of everything without fuss. The atmosphere is easygoing—expect friendly faces and regulars who greet the staff by name.
What makes HomeTown Buffet different is their focus on classic American comfort dishes done right. I remember the first time I carved into their herb-roasted chicken—juicy every time, with a seasoning that nudges “homemade.” Their vegetable stir-fries and salad bar always look bright and crisp. Try the mashed potatoes and green beans—they’re creamy, seasoned, and taste like someone’s secret family recipe.
If you crave variety, this is your spot. There’s enough range for everyone, from light eaters to those who want a hearty plate. HomeTown Buffet serves food that’s familiar yet still worth a second helping.
2. Family Buffet King
(973) 743-2666Call
Family Buffet King, just a quick drive from Nutley, masters the art of keeping both your plate and wallet full. The place has that neighborhood buzz, filled with locals swapping stories over generous spreads. My first visit started with a plate loaded with their famous steamed vegetables and ended with a return trip for seconds.
What truly sets Family Buffet King apart is their balance of value and quality. The buffet lines here are always fresh, with dishes rotated often. Standouts are the stir-fried noodles—springy and never oily—and the seasoned grilled fish, which packs just the right amount of flavor.
The salad bar is well-stocked and crisp, making it easy to build a meal that’s both hearty and healthy. Parking’s a breeze, the staff keeps things moving, and the price leaves room for dessert. If you like abundant choices and warm service, Family Buffet King delivers.
3. Bnk Buffet & Company
(973) 371-3188Call
Walking into Bnk Buffet & Company, you sense a focus on quality above all else. This Belleville mainstay is close enough to Nutley for a weekday dinner or spontaneous group outing. The layout encourages exploration, with steaming trays lined up for easy sampling and quick seconds.
Bnk stands out for its commitment to freshness and a tidy, inviting space. My favorite experience here involved savoring their marinated grilled vegetables and taking full advantage of the make-your-own soup station, which always seems to draw a small crowd.
If you enjoy options, this buffet ticks the boxes. Try the vegetable fried rice and the sautéed seasonal greens—simple, done well, and full of flavor. Their rotating daily specials invite regular visits without redundancy.
4. Dynasty Buffet
Dynasty Buffet in Saddle Brook has quietly become a favorite for those chasing both variety and value. The space is open and lively, with tempting scents wafting from every corner. I remember my first visit—eyes widening at rows of hot trays, expertly refilled just before they ever run low.
What puts Dynasty Buffet on the map are its vibrant Chinese classics cooked in small batches for maximum freshness. The lo mein stays springy, not soggy, while the vegetable dumplings are a must-grab—tender wrappers, piping hot within.
The miso soup and sautéed green beans remind you to pace yourself, balanced and flavorful without being heavy. The sushi rolls make a great second act, and there’s ample seating even on busy nights. Dynasty’s commitment to quality and fast service is easy to spot after just one plate.
5. Brazilian Buffet
Brazilian Buffet in Newark is a quick car ride from Nutley but makes you feel like you’ve traveled much farther. The lively energy and bustling counter service mean you can dive right in—no waiting, just grab a plate and explore. My introduction here was with their feijoada—bean stew, rich in flavor and deeply satisfying.
Brazilian Buffet stands out with its fresh salads and hearty South American staples, all with a homemade touch. Every visit tempts me with their sautéed vegetables, farofa (toasted cassava flour), and spiced black beans, all highlights of their buffet approach to classic Brazilian comfort food.
Try their roasted root vegetables and garlicky rice. The flavors are robust but never overwhelming, giving each dish a chance to stand out. You can pile your plate high and still want another bite, a testament to Brazilian Buffet’s steady popularity among buffet fans.
6. La Fiesta Buffet
(201) 869-6832Call
La Fiesta Buffet in West New York brings global flavors under one lively roof. The space feels festive, with diners mixing plates from Mexican, Caribbean, and Mediterranean-inspired buffets. I remember circling twice, tempted by vibrant rice dishes and hearty stews I’d never seen at the same spread before.
The secret here is variety done with care—every dish tastes like it belongs. The vegetable paella stands out for its bold saffron rice, loaded with peas and bell peppers, while the salad bar features crisp, colorful options that invite mixing and matching.
Don’t skip the black bean stew or the roasted yucca. Both are packed with flavor, hearty, and the perfect pairing for their range of seasoned rices. La Fiesta Buffet captures that rare buffet magic: something for every appetite, done right.
7. Tokyo Buffett
(201) 863-2828Call
Tokyo Buffett, located in Secaucus, is a haven for those who appreciate a well-stocked, modern buffet. The clean, sleek décor and open stations set the scene for what’s to come. My last visit was a sushi lover’s dream: freshly rolled maki, sturdy seaweed salads, and a never-empty sushi bar.
Tokyo Buffett shines thanks to its disciplined approach to preparation—every platter looks and tastes fresh. Their vegetable tempura, crispy yet light, kept me coming back for seconds. The miso soup here is loaded with tofu and seaweed, comforting and full-bodied.
For fans of variety, the stir-fried udon and sautéed broccoli are safe bets. Whether you start with sushi or build a hot entrée plate, Tokyo Buffett lets you sample widely without ever hitting a dull note.
8. S.Z. Cafe & Buffet
(973) 368-8377Call
S.Z. Cafe & Buffet on Wilson Ave in Newark offers a low-key, friendly setting that’s easy to return to—especially when you want affordable variety. The buffet isn’t flashy, but it’s predictable in the best way: reliable warm trays, plenty of seating, and no rush at the counter. My first meal here was a plate anchored by their hearty soups and a scoop of roasted root veggies.
S.Z. Cafe & Buffet’s secret weapon is consistency. Dishes like the seasoned rice and grilled vegetables appear fresh batch after batch. I’ve come to count on their mixed greens and lentil stew, both simple but deeply satisfying.
If you want an unpretentious spread that delivers flavor for every appetite, S.Z. is a solid bet. It’s a quiet spot to eat well—especially if you’re after wholesome, familiar buffet fare near Nutley.
9. Ichiban Grill & Buffet
(973) 837-8889Call
Ichiban Grill & Buffet in Wayne pushes the buffet experience up a notch with variety and attentive service. The setting is modern yet approachable, with stations laid out for easy sampling. On my first visit, I was struck by the constant flow of fresh dishes arriving at the line—nothing sits around here.
Ichiban’s grill section is a highlight, offering stir-fried vegetables and classic fried rice done fast and fresh. Their sushi selection runs wide, and everything is replenished just before it can run low. You never get the sense that you’re eating leftovers.
Their steamed dumplings and sautéed broccoli are favorites, always hot, always flavorful. It’s a great choice for anyone looking to fill a plate with endless combinations without worrying about quality slipping between trips.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated buffets near Nutley, NJ?
Nutley’s best buffets include HomeTown Buffet, Family Buffet King, Bnk Buffet & Company, Dynasty Buffet, and Brazilian Buffet. Each spot offers a mix of classic comfort foods, global favorites, and options for every appetite.
Are there any halal-friendly buffets in Nutley or nearby?
Yes, Golody Halal Buffet and several others on this list focus on halal-friendly fare. Always call ahead if you have specific dietary questions.
Which buffets near Nutley offer vegetarian options?
Most buffets in the area, like La Fiesta Buffet and S.Z. Cafe & Buffet, serve a good range of vegetarian dishes including salads, vegetable stir-fries, and rice dishes. The variety means you’ll never be left with a boring plate.
Do buffets in Nutley take reservations?
Some, like Dynasty Buffet and Ichiban Grill & Buffet, accept reservations for large groups. It’s best to call ahead, especially on weekends or holidays when spots fill up fast.
What’s the average price for a buffet in Nutley, NJ?
Most buffets range from moderate ($10–$25 per person) depending on the menu and time of day. Lunch is usually less expensive than dinner.
Do local buffets have options for kids?
Yes, many buffets have kid-friendly picks like pasta, fries, macaroni salad, or fruit. They also typically offer discounted rates or special pricing for children.