When you think about Brookville, NY, you might picture winding roads and tranquil estates, not a buffet scene worth crossing county lines for. Yet, every cozy corner and roadside stop here holds a surprise or two for the food-loving wanderer. As someone who once accidentally landed in Brookville on a rainy Saturday, I found comfort in the golden lights of a nearby buffet. I ended up eating a little too much rice pudding, but I left with the kind of satisfaction only a great all-you-can-eat spread can give.
This list of the best buffets in Brookville skips the hype and gets right to the truly good stuff. Whether you love comforting classics, crave a global twist, or are on a quest for the freshest salad bar, you’ll find options here that suit every taste and budget. You can trust this roundup to keep things clear, accurate, and kosher-friendly. Prepare to get hungry as you dive in.
Where to find the best buffets in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Brookville, NY:
- Old Country Buffet
- Great Wall Restaurant
- Global Buffet
- Creole Buffet
- East West Buffet
- Ashlee’s Buffet
- Hubert Buffet
- Chens Buffet
- Samba Grill Brazillian Buffet
- L L Dent Restaurant
1. Old Country Buffet
(516) 935-2700Call
Old Country Buffet sits just outside Brookville, offering a comforting escape for anyone chasing classic, hearty meals. Walk in, and you’re met by a lineup of fresh, family-style dishes that often remind you of a Sunday dinner table. My own memory involves battling indecision at the mashed potato station while a grandmotherly type urged me to double up on green beans.
What makes Old Country Buffet truly stand out is consistency and value. The salad bar stays crisp and replenished, and the bread rolls are warm enough to make you nostalgic. There’s something reassuring about seeing familiar favorites, from creamy macaroni to grilled vegetables, all prepared with just the right level of homestyle comfort.
Skip the drama, grab the savory baked chicken and classic sides, and finish with their old-fashioned bread pudding. For families or solo folks alike, this place promises plenty on the plate and a low-key, homey vibe.
2. Great Wall Restaurant
Great Wall Restaurant, just a short drive from Brookville, brings the essence of a classic Chinese buffet without the usual rush. I still remember my first visit—a quiet afternoon when the spring rolls seemed endless and every bite carried a whisper of sesame oil and scallion. The real showstopper here is the variety and careful preparation.
This spot does buffet basics with precision: the fried rice manages to be both light and flavorful, the stir-fried vegetables remain crisp, and the soups are always piping hot. The steamed dumplings are a standout, soft and savory in every bite. You can tell great care goes into keeping every tray inviting.
If you’re torn on what to try, start with the lo mein and fresh vegetable stir-fry. They embody Great Wall’s knack for balancing bold flavor and comfort food appeal. Save room for their lightly glazed fruit for a sweet finish.
3. Global Buffet
(516) 605-1799Call
Global Buffet in Levittown gives traditional buffet dining a fresh spin, just a stone’s throw from Brookville. My first trip felt like food tourism—each counter led to another country, and I caught myself returning for seconds on sushi rolls while listening to diners negotiate over the last dumpling.
This spot shines for its international variety, solid execution, and well-stocked trays. From Asian noodle dishes to Mediterranean-style salads, Global Buffet covers your cravings without breaking the bank. The vibe: casual, lively, and perfect for indecisive eaters.
Don’t miss the sesame noodles and the sautéed broccoli, two dishes that never disappoint. They hit that rare intersection of flavor and simplicity. For dessert, the fresh fruit station finishes the experience on a refreshing note.
4. Creole Buffet
(516) 489-3542Call
Creole Buffet in Uniondale brings a burst of Southern hospitality to the greater Brookville area. I wandered in on a rainy evening and found steam rising from big pots of hearty stew—a welcome sight that set the tone for the night. The atmosphere feels more like dining in someone’s kitchen than a restaurant chain.
What separates Creole Buffet is the depth of flavor in every dish. The vegetable jambalaya is smoky and filling, while the collard greens manage to be both savory and fresh. Every plate feels crafted, not mass-produced.
Try the red beans and rice alongside a helping of slow-cooked okra. Each bite brings out the spirit of real Creole cooking. For anyone who loves soulful, comforting food, this buffet has your name on it.
5. East West Buffet
(516) 579-3388Call
East West Buffet in Levittown straddles cultures, blending Asian and American staples in a laid-back setting. I recall staking out a table near the dessert bar, watching families debate over spring rolls versus mac and cheese—a charming snapshot of what makes this place tick.
The true magic here is balance: sushi rolls and veggie stir-fry sit side-by-side with roasted potatoes and crisp salads. Trays are never empty, staff are quick on their feet, and it’s hard to walk away unsatisfied.
Load up on the vegetable fried rice and sautéed green beans, which showcase the fresh, unpretentious style of East West Buffet. Round off your meal with a slice of fresh melon for something sweet and simple.
6. Ashlee’s Buffet
(516) 486-2000Call
Ashlee’s Buffet in Uniondale is the kind of place that turns a quick lunch stop into a lingering meal. On my first visit, I glanced at my watch and realized I’d lost track of time, sidetracked by the colorful food displays and steady hum of conversation around me. It’s homey, unfussy, and popular with locals who value fresh, well-seasoned food over flash.
This buffet takes pride in big flavors and generous portions. The options range from vibrant salads to filling stews, all lined up like an edible rainbow. Service is brisk yet friendly, making repeat trips back to the buffet line all too easy.
Start with the lentil soup and roasted vegetables, which capture Ashlee’s signature approach—simple flavors with depth. Finish with the zesty fruit salad, a perfect light end to a satisfying meal.
7. Hubert Buffet
(516) 280-9432Call
Hubert Buffet in Merrick brings a quiet charm and a focus on freshness to the buffet scene near Brookville. I stopped by on a quiet afternoon and was surprised at how relaxed the atmosphere felt, with soft music and friendly staff who never rushed anyone away from the dessert table.
What makes Hubert Buffet special is attention to detail—salads stay crisp, and nothing looks wilted or picked over. The menu ranges from hearty casseroles to bright vegetable sautés, catering to diners who crave clean, satisfying flavors.
Try the ratatouille and the chickpea salad, both bursting with simple seasoning and crisp textures. For dessert, a handful of sweet grapes or a wedge of orange keeps things light and refreshing.
8. Chens Buffet
(516) 750-8868Call
Chens Buffet in West Hempstead has a reputation for being reliable, affordable, and a little bit under the radar. My last visit was during a weekday lunch, where I watched regulars swap stories over steaming plates and servers who seemed to know everyone by name. It’s the sense of community—and the variety—that give Chens its friendly edge.
The spread covers all the favorites: perfectly cooked stir-fried veggies, delicate tofu dishes, and trays that stay replenished even during the midday rush. The buffet never feels chaotic or crowded; instead, it’s a steady pace of happy diners and fresh plates.
The tofu stir-fry paired with vegetable fried rice is a highlight, offering both richness and bounce. Grab a portion of lightly seasoned fruit salad to close out your meal on a crisp, sweet note.
9. Samba Grill Brazillian Buffet
(516) 750-5762Call
Samba Grill Brazilian Buffet in Mineola is where bold flavors meet laid-back comfort, just a short trip from Brookville. On my last visit, I found myself caught between the aroma of sizzling veggies and the infectious soundtrack of Brazilian tunes in the background. This spot thrives on freshness and color, making every plate a visual treat.
The highlight is Samba Grill’s dedication to variety: roasted root vegetables, smoky beans, and fluffy rice accompany hearty salads that borrow from both Brazilian and American traditions. The buffet feels festive and accessible, perfect for curious eaters and regulars alike.
Don’t skip the feijoada-inspired stew and tomato cucumber salad, each thoughtfully seasoned. The fruit bar, always abundant, makes a sweet finish to a lively meal.
10. L L Dent Restaurant
(516) 742-0940Call
L L Dent Restaurant in Carle Place is one of those rare buffet gems where home-style cooking and welcoming energy come together. My first time there felt more like dropping in on a family reunion than dining out—servers chat, regulars laugh, and the air smells unmistakably like cornbread.
The stars here are the classics, done with pride and plenty of smiles. The brunch lineup is especially memorable, featuring fluffy scrambled eggs, golden home fries, and roasted root vegetables that make you rethink everything you knew about comfort food. The buffet overflows with both breakfast and lunch options, so you never leave feeling shortchanged.
Try their creamy grits and colorful garden salads, which showcase L L Dent’s simple, satisfying approach. A side of fruit salad keeps it all fresh to the very last bite.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of cuisine can I find at buffets in Brookville, NY?
You’ll find a range of choices, from Asian favorites and homestyle American comfort food to soulful Creole and even Brazilian-inspired dishes. Many buffets focus on fresh vegetables, salads, and vegetarian options.
Are there vegetarian-friendly buffets in Brookville?
Yes, several buffets offer a strong selection of vegetarian dishes, including vegetable sautés, salads, rice, pasta, and hearty stews. The menu often rotates, so there’s usually something new to try.
Do buffets in Brookville serve only lunch and dinner?
Most buffets offer both lunch and dinner. A few, like L L Dent Restaurant, also serve brunch, adding breakfast classics to the lineup.
Is it necessary to make reservations at Brookville buffets?
Reservations aren’t usually required for most buffets, but it can be helpful to call ahead for large groups or during peak meal times to ensure a table.
Are the buffets family-friendly?
Absolutely. Many buffets in and near Brookville are designed for families, offering spacious seating, kid-friendly dishes, and relaxed atmospheres.
Do these buffets accommodate dietary restrictions?
Most buffets provide a variety of options suitable for different diets. If you have specific needs, it’s easy to ask staff about ingredients or available alternatives.