Finding a great buffet in Centereach, NY feels a bit like opening a treasure chest. Few dining options match the anticipation of rows of steaming dishes, each one ready to surprise you. Over the years, I’ve navigated these steam-table landscapes, from family brunches to spur-of-the-moment dinners. One favorite memory: unlimited soft, fluffy bread rolls at a well-loved Centereach spot, which always disappeared off my plate before anything else could even arrive.
What really sets the top buffets apart isn’t just variety—it’s the sense that someone’s actually tasted the food before it made it to your plate. Good buffets don’t rely on spectacle, but on quality and freshness. If you want to know where to find more than just lukewarm standards, you’re in the right place. Let’s dig into the best buffets Centereach has to offer and help you skip straight to the satisfying part.
Where to find the best buffets in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Centereach, NY:
- Buffet Express
- Old Country Buffet
- Bhr Corp
- Good Taste Buffet
- Sunny Buffet
- Empire Buffet
- Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
- Ruby Buffet Inc
- Creole Buffet
- East West Buffet
1. Buffet Express
(631) 981-8243Call
Buffet Express sits just outside Centereach and draws locals for its simple, no-nonsense approach to buffet dining. On my last visit, the staff greeted everyone with genuine smiles, and the food stations were never empty. Service here feels personal in a way that bigger chains often miss.
The atmosphere keeps things relaxed and easy, yet the food selection is where Buffet Express really shines. Trays are always refreshed, ensuring top-notch freshness with every serving.
Definitely try the stir-fried vegetables or the herb-roasted potatoes— both bursting with flavor. The freshly baked bread balances the meal perfectly. Buffet Express proves that a buffet doesn’t need flash to deliver comfort and satisfaction.
2. Old Country Buffet
Old Country Buffet shapes every meal around comfort, with a rotating selection that reminds you of a weekend gathering at home. On my recent visit, I noticed families returning for second helpings and sharing quiet laughs between plates. There’s an ease about this place that makes guests linger.
The buffet line is packed with options that celebrate wholesome cooking. Home-style vegetables and seasoned rice are always fresh, balanced by occasional surprises like a zesty pasta salad. Every dish tastes as if it was made with an eye for tradition.
If you go, don’t miss the classic mashed potatoes with their light texture. The vegetable medley, particularly when paired with a side of warm rolls, defines the straightforward and satisfying heart of Old Country Buffet.
3. Bhr Corp
(631) 543-9583Call
Bhr Corp quietly impresses with its well-organized buffet and attentive service. The moment I stepped in, I noticed everything felt thoughtfully put together. There’s a steady flow of fresh food, and the staff keep an eye on every table, ready for refills or questions.
Buffet choices are varied, but quality never slips. The vegetable curry, mild and perfectly spiced, is a standout, and the lentil soup stays comforting no matter how many bowls you pour. The salad bar is crisp, with plenty of fresh choices for every plate.
Try the vegetable biryani if you’re looking for something filling yet light. It’s a flavor highlight that underscores Bhr Corp’s dedication to taste and satisfaction.
4. Good Taste Buffet
(631) 543-9583Call
Good Taste Buffet lives up to its name with a spread that’s generous and inviting. I remember a laid-back lunch here, where the aromas alone hinted at the freshness behind the line of woks. There’s something easygoing about watching plates quickly fill up with favorites.
The buffet puts together classic Chinese dishes and Asian standards. The vegetable fried rice stays consistently fluffy and full of flavor, while the sautéed green beans always offer a crisp bite. Choices are simple, but there’s care in the details.
If you enjoy variety, load up on the vegetable lo mein and steamed broccoli—both showcase what makes Good Taste Buffet a reliable pick. Their ability to keep comfort and flavor in balance truly stands out.
5. Sunny Buffet
(631) 665-6050Call
Sunny Buffet brings a cheerful vibe and steady foot traffic, thanks to its dependable lineup of buffet favorites. I recall stopping in on a rainy day—the warm lights and bustle inside felt like a welcome escape. Here, it’s easy to become a regular without even realizing it.
The buffet setup covers a wide range, with attention to both freshness and pace. Trays of steamed dumplings and stir-fried vegetables are always replenished just as they start to empty. Every visit feels in sync with the kitchen’s rhythm.
Sample their egg drop soup for a gentle start, then pile high on the sautéed mixed vegetables. Sunny Buffet blends comfort with a dash of brightness, living up to its name in more ways than one.
6. Empire Buffet
(631) 874-4200Call
Empire Buffet sits at the intersection of selection and simplicity, creating a spot where picking a favorite isn’t easy. My visits here have always revolved around the buzz that fills the room—everyone seems locked in a mission to discover something new on each round.
The buffet highlights a strong spread of Asian-inspired dishes. The crispy spring rolls and fresh sautéed bok choy strike the right balance between flavor and texture, while the fried rice consistently backs up every other main.
If you like to build variety on your plate, start with their tender steamed vegetables and continue with a ladle of hot and sour soup. Empire Buffet stands out through reliable, straightforward satisfaction.
7. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
(631) 620-3688Call
Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc takes the buffet experience up a notch with its lively grill station and diverse array of options. On my last stop here, the inviting scent from the grill made it hard to focus on anything but what was sizzling behind the glass. There’s an energy to the service that keeps the atmosphere upbeat without any rush.
Diners line up for the grill, but the rest of the spread holds its own. The stir-fried noodles and lightly seasoned vegetable medleys show off layers of flavor and attention to timing. The salads are always fresh and surprisingly imaginative for a buffet setting.
If you’re feeling bold, assemble your own plate at the grill with your choice of vegetables. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc puts the fun in buffet dining without missing a beat on taste.
8. Ruby Buffet Inc
(516) 882-0300Call
Ruby Buffet Inc has a low-key charm, thanks to its convenient location and wide-reaching buffet tables. I remember ducking in during a shopping trip, appreciating how easy it was to find something fresh and satisfying without any wait.
The offerings range from lighter choices to classic Asian staples. The steamed broccoli and vegetable lo mein stood out not just for their taste but for their obvious freshness. Each tray is replenished quickly, and it’s not unusual to catch staff sampling to ensure quality.
If you want a customized meal, start with their build-your-own noodle bowl and top it with plenty of sautéed vegetables. Ruby Buffet Inc earns repeat visits for its fuss-free experience and consistently good buffet fare.
9. Creole Buffet
(516) 489-3542Call
Creole Buffet brings something different to the table, offering a vibrant take on buffet dining that stands out amid the usual fare. Walking in, I was struck by the bold aromas and bright colors lining the buffet tables—a sign that this is not your standard spread.
The focus here is on seasoning and texture. The vegetable jambalaya delivers warmth with every bite, and the collard greens are slow-cooked and savory. There’s a sense of care and tradition in each dish.
For a real taste of the kitchen, try the spiced corn and red beans. Creole Buffet manages to pack big flavors into every serving, making it a memorable stop for anyone seeking fresh variety.
10. East West Buffet
(516) 579-3388Call
East West Buffet makes dining interesting by marrying flavors from both sides of the globe. My first meal here started as an experiment but quickly became a repeat adventure—there’s real excitement in strolling down aisles where stir-fry sits beside lighter Western classics.
The standout for me was the garlic green beans alongside a fresh Caesar salad. It’s a mix that captures the best of the East West Buffet approach: variety without confusion. Choices always feel intentional and balanced.
If you’re a fan of fusion, try pairing sautéed tofu with their roasted potato wedges. East West Buffet succeeds at making familiar dishes feel just adventurous enough for anyone willing to fill their plate differently each visit.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of cuisine can I find at buffets in Centereach, NY?
Most buffets offer a range of Asian, American, and fusion dishes, with some specializing in comfort food or vegetarian options. You’ll find everything from stir-fried vegetables to fresh salads and classic rice dishes.
Are there vegetarian or vegan-friendly buffets in Centereach, NY?
Yes, several buffets feature strong vegetarian and vegan selections. Look for salad bars, sautéed vegetable platters, and plant-based curries on most menus for a satisfying meat-free meal.
Is it necessary to make reservations at Centereach buffets?
Reservations aren’t usually needed for most buffets. However, calling ahead can be smart for larger groups or during busy weekends, especially at popular spots.
Do local buffets offer takeout or delivery?
Many buffets now offer takeout for their most popular dishes. Some also provide delivery—just call ahead to check or look for the option on their website or delivery apps.
What are some signature dishes to try at Centereach buffets?
Try the steamed vegetable dumplings, stir-fried noodles, and seasoned rice platters. These dishes tend to capture the strengths of buffet dining in the area, highlighting both freshness and variety.
