Buffet-hunting in Deer Park, NY can surprise even the most seasoned foodie. This corner of Long Island offers an inviting range of all-you-can-eat spots, from homey delis to spread-heavy Asian grills, each adding their own flavor to the local dining scene. My first Deer Park buffet run took me from the mellow aroma of fresh bagels at a family spot to tables wrapped in the sizzle of Asian stir fry. There’s something oddly satisfying about watching platters refill just as fast as they disappear.
Finding a solid buffet in Deer Park is less about luck and more about knowing where to look. Whether you’re after a generous Sunday brunch, a no-frills lunch, or a relaxed dinner, this area gives you real options. The choices on this list have you covered, whether your cravings lean toward classic comfort food, halal options, or an international smorgasbord. Let’s dig into where you’ll actually want to stack your plate.
Where to find the best buffets in Deer Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Deer Park, NY:
- Papacino’s Bagels, Deli & Catering
- Old Country Buffet
- Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
- Bhr Corp
- Good Taste Buffet
- East West Buffet
- Ruby Buffet Inc
- Sunny Buffet
- Creole Buffet
- Buffet Express
1. Papacino’s Bagels, Deli & Catering
Nestled on Bay Shore Road, Papacino’s Bagels, Deli & Catering draws locals for breakfast and lunch buffets with a homemade touch. It’s the kind of spot where the scent of fresh bagels sets the tone for the day, and the deli counter never disappoints. I once stopped in for the breakfast spread; the bagels were still warm, and the cream cheese selection kept me lingering.
The buffet shines with soft, chewy bagels, fluffy scrambled eggs, and platters of smoked salmon for a classic New York experience. If you crave more, sample their hearty potato salads and deli meats. For a standout plate, stack your bagel with eggs and add a slice of tomato—the kind of details that turn a meal into a ritual.
2. Old Country Buffet
(631) 549-1023Call
Old Country Buffet carries the kind of charm you associate with family gatherings and comfort food. Tucked not far from Deer Park, it’s where locals bond over plates stacked with crowd-pleasers. I’ve found myself drawn to the warm, inviting atmosphere—one where you can relax and let your cravings take the lead.
The hot buffet trays brim with fresh vegetables, mashed potatoes, and golden corn that taste like someone’s grandmother is running the kitchen. Customizable salad bars make healthy choices easy, while a rotating lineup of soups keeps things interesting. My favorite move is building a classic veggie plate, then sneaking a scoop of their creamy mac and cheese on the side for good measure.
Old Country Buffet is all about variety and unpretentious comfort. It’s a place where anyone can feel at home—without ever leaving hungry.
3. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
(631) 620-3688Call
Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc is where you head when indecision hits and every craving deserves a chance. Located in West Babylon, this spot blends the best of Asian and American fare, all at a price point that won’t dent your wallet. My first visit was sparked by a friend’s enthusiasm for their stir-fry station—and now I understand the hype.
The buffet lineup is vast, mixing sushi rolls, lo mein, crisp salads, and hot grilled vegetables in equal measure. The hibachi grill stands out, where you can pile your plate high and watch it sizzle to order. I keep coming back for their lightly seasoned shrimp and the endless vegetable medley—they never skimp on freshness or flavor.
If you’re after variety, Flaming Grill is a reliable crowd-pleaser that keeps things lively and well-stocked from lunch through dinner.
4. Bhr Corp
(631) 543-9583Call
Bhr Corp isn’t just another buffet stop—it’s a staple in the Commack area for those who like to keep things simple yet satisfying. When I visited, I was struck by the friendly staff and the ease of filling my plate without overwhelming choices. Here, it’s about quality over quantity, with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and a welcoming setting.
The buffet features classic American dishes with a handful of international surprises. The standout for me was their well-seasoned roasted vegetables and perfectly cooked pasta salads. It’s clear they focus on freshness, and the balance on the buffet makes repeat visits easy.
If you’re seeking a straightforward, clean buffet experience, Bhr Corp delivers with honest flavors and reliable variety. The comfort food here feels thoughtfully prepared and never rushed.
5. Good Taste Buffet
(631) 543-9583Call
Good Taste Buffet sits in the Mayfair Shopping Center, making it a favorite for shoppers and locals needing a quick, generous lunch. During my last visit, I appreciated how well the buffet balanced price and quality—proof that a below-average tab doesn’t mean below-average food.
The spread is classic Chinese-American, heavy on fresh stir-fries, steamed veggies, and perfectly cooked lo mein. If you’re a fan of lighter options, their sautéed green beans and tofu leave a fresh impression. What stands out is the consistency; trays refill quickly, and the kitchen pays attention to detail.
Don’t miss the made-to-order stir fry bar. Customizing a plate with your favorite vegetables and sauces always feels like a win at this no-fuss spot.
6. East West Buffet
(516) 579-3388Call
East West Buffet is the answer for those looking to roam between Asian and American flavors under one roof. My last lunch here felt like a small culinary tour—one plate was stacked with garlicky green beans, the next with crisp salads and steamed rice. The variety keeps your taste buds guessing, and nothing feels rushed or repetitive.
What separates East West Buffet is its balance. Here, you find classic Chinese favorites side by side with American comfort dishes, all priced sensibly. I gravitate toward their vegetable stir fries and always find some surprise in the rotating hot food section.
Build a colorful plate from the plentiful veggie and salad bars, then finish with one of their fresh fruit offerings for a meal that’s both satisfying and bright.
7. Ruby Buffet Inc
(516) 882-0300Call
Ruby Buffet Inc in East Massapequa is that rare find—a mall buffet that doesn’t settle for average. The location makes it a practical pause during a shopping marathon, but the food is what brings people back. When I visited, the pace was lively, and the steam tables were always brimming.
This buffet stands out for its carefully prepared Asian dishes and attentive staff. The kitchen keeps a steady supply of vegetable stir-fry, crisp spring rolls, and an inviting salad selection that works well for meatless diners. I never miss the made-to-order noodle bar, ideal for customizing your meal with fresh vegetables and sauces.
Ruby Buffet Inc blends convenience with quality, making it a reliable choice for anyone looking to eat well without fuss.
8. Sunny Buffet
(631) 665-6050Call
Sunny Buffet in Bay Shore catches both weekday lunch crowds and families looking for easy weekend meals. My first time here, I was struck by just how inviting the atmosphere felt—wide spaces, easy parking, and a team that keeps things moving with a smile. It’s the sort of place where regulars and newcomers mingle over a plate.
The buffet offers a solid spread of Asian-inspired classics: think vegetable fried rice, hot soups, and crunchy sautéed greens. Always reliable, their selection of fresh fruit and salad options is perfect if you like to start light. When I want a little more comfort, I reach for the soft noodles and steamed vegetables that never disappoint.
Sunny Buffet keeps things approachable, with good food, reasonable prices, and a setting that welcomes everyone.
9. Creole Buffet
(516) 489-3542Call
Creole Buffet in Uniondale delivers soulful flavors not often found on Long Island’s buffet scene. On my first visit, I was met with bold aromas and a genuinely warm, welcoming staff. This is a place where every plate feels like a small adventure, with colors and spices that transport you straight to New Orleans without ever leaving New York.
The buffet line shines with rice dishes, savory stews, and slow-cooked vegetables. For something that stands out, load up your plate with their seasoned beans and fluffy rice—simple, filling, and deeply satisfying. Their sautéed greens and classic potato dishes also claim plenty of fans among regulars.
Creole Buffet stands out by serving comfort with a dash of zest, making it a must-try for lovers of hearty, flavorful fare.
10. Buffet Express
(631) 981-8243Call
Buffet Express in Ronkonkoma is proof that buffet-style dining can be friendly, fast, and surprisingly satisfying. My first visit was on a hurried weekday, yet I never once felt rushed. The staff are quick to help, and the vibe is casual—think of it as a pit stop for comfort and quick choices.
The focus here is on fresh, hot food that rotates with the seasons. Expect veggie-heavy stir-fries, crunchy salads, and daily specials that offer something new to try. The rice dishes, always steaming and fragrant, became my personal favorite after just one taste.
Buffet Express delivers a well-edited menu for diners looking for a simple, consistent buffet spot that doesn’t try to do too much—and gets the essentials right.
More Things to Try in Deer Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I expect from buffets in Deer Park, NY?
Expect a mix of Asian, American, and international dishes, with many spots offering a blend of classic comfort food and lighter options. Most buffets keep things fresh and affordable, making them great for small groups or families.
Are there halal buffet options in Deer Park?
Yes, some buffets in the area specifically offer halal choices. It’s always best to call ahead and confirm with the restaurant for up-to-date menu options.
Can I find vegetarian or vegan-friendly buffets in Deer Park?
Many buffets include a variety of vegetarian, vegan, and plant-based dishes. Look for fresh vegetable stir-fries, salad bars, rice, and noodle stations for plenty of tasty meatless options.
Do these buffets offer takeout or delivery?
Several buffets, like Papacino’s Bagels, Deli & Catering, provide both takeout and delivery. Check each restaurant’s website or call directly for their current ordering options.
Is parking easy at Deer Park buffets?
Most buffets in the area have ample parking or are located within shopping centers, so parking tends to be convenient and free.
