Buffets in Holbrook, NY have a knack for turning an ordinary meal into a small adventure. You step inside, plate in hand, and every table offers a new decision—crisp salads on one side, fragrant entrees on another, each option ready to break the routine of midday or night. Holbrook’s buffet scene balances comfort with surprise. On my last trip, I stumbled across a silent competition at the dessert bar: who could build the tallest ice cream cone. No winner was crowned, but the laughter was worth a second visit.
This guide is your shortcut to the most memorable buffets in Holbrook—spots where good food keeps locals coming back. I’ve spent more hours than I’d admit to, sampling, rating, and quietly judging mashed potatoes for fluffiness. Whatever your mood, there’s a buffet on this list ready to serve up abundance and a story or two. Let’s explore the best places to eat your fill, one plate at a time.
Where to find the best buffets in Holbrook, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Holbrook, NY:
- Irish Times Pub
- Buffet Express
- Old Country Buffet
- Empire Buffet
- Bhr Corp
- Good Taste Buffet
- Sunny Buffet
- Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
- Ruby Buffet Inc
- Creole Buffet
1. Irish Times Pub
Irish Times Pub feels like a warm gathering spot right on Main Street. The buffet here blends hearty Irish favorites with American classics, so there’s a satisfying choice for everyone. Every visit, I catch myself lingering at the buffet’s shepherd’s pie, the savory meat and creamy potatoes always pull me back for seconds.
Their brunch buffet stands out for its fresh scones and fluffy eggs, which pair perfectly with strong coffee and good company. The pub’s layout helps—plenty of space, inviting wood booths, and natural light set the mood. If you want a little tradition and a lot of comfort, this spot makes it hard to leave hungry.
2. Buffet Express
(631) 981-8243Call
Buffet Express is the kind of place where portions suit any appetite and the food arrives hot and fast. This buffet packs a surprising variety into a relaxed, no-fuss setting, making it easy to linger over lunch or breeze through a quick dinner. I stopped by with friends last week, and we traded favorite finds with every trip back to the buffet line.
The standout here is the selection of fresh vegetable stir-fries and well-cooked chicken dishes. Each tray is replenished often, so the flavors keep their punch. The fried rice is light but packed with taste, and the steamed veggies add color to every plate. If you want a simple yet satisfying meal, Buffet Express delivers.
3. Old Country Buffet
Old Country Buffet feels like stepping inside a well-kept tradition. The buffet’s strength is comfort food done right, from creamy mashed potatoes to baked fish that flakes at the touch of a fork. I always find myself going back for their macaroni and cheese, which is as rich and smooth as you’d hope.
Families fill the tables for a reason. Trays of green beans, roasted chicken, and freshly baked bread make this spot feel like a welcoming dining room. The salad bar features crisp greens and house-made dressings—worth piling high. If you appreciate a buffet that warms you up and brings back those Sunday dinner vibes, Old Country Buffet is tough to top.
4. Empire Buffet
(631) 874-4200Call
Empire Buffet draws a crowd with its generous spread and steady quality. There’s always something new to try, from crisp vegetable medleys to saucy chicken options that never disappoint. The dining room buzzes with families sharing plates, and the parking is never a headache.
The highlight here is the made-to-order stir-fry station. Watching the cooks toss fresh ginger and colorful veggies into the sizzling pan is half the fun. The lo mein is especially good, perfectly springy and never greasy. If you crave a spot that balances dependable favorites with a few surprises, Empire Buffet pulls it off without any fuss.
5. Bhr Corp
(631) 543-9583Call
Bhr Corp doesn’t jump out with flashy decor, but the buffet makes its mark on flavor. This spot is all about consistency and generous portions. The variety here impressed me—hearty soups and colorful vegetable dishes always line the counter, kept fresh through busy evenings.
Fans rave about the seasoned roasted potatoes and perfectly cooked steamed broccoli. Each bite feels thoughtfully prepared, never bland or overdone. My go-to is the wild rice pilaf, which balances texture and flavor with every serving. For anyone after a reliable, no-nonsense buffet with solid choices, Bhr Corp quietly delivers on its promise.
6. Good Taste Buffet
(631) 543-9583Call
Good Taste Buffet at the Mayfair Shopping Center offers a feast that doesn’t drain your wallet. The buffet here manages a rich variety for such an affordable price, spanning classic Chinese dishes, fresh salads, and stir-fried veggies. My last visit ended with a conversation about who makes the best dumplings—Good Taste’s came up, soft and flavorful every time.
The garlic string beans and sesame noodles are two crowd favorites. The buffet stays well stocked, so each plate feels freshly made. For those with an appetite for Chinese and Asian classics, this spot delivers comfort and flavor at a pace perfect for families or a quiet solo meal.
7. Sunny Buffet
(631) 665-6050Call
Sunny Buffet lives up to its name, feeling bright and open from the moment you step in. The buffet is always fresh, with a colorful spread of vegetable-based dishes and perfectly seasoned rice. There’s a local buzz around their steamed broccoli and sautéed mushrooms, both fitting picks for clean, satisfying flavor.
The stir-fried noodles are a favorite, layered with crisp veggies and subtle spice that invite seconds. On weekends, the lunch crowd packs in but the service never misses a beat. Last time I visited, someone nearby was praising the sweet-and-sour cauliflower, and it didn’t disappoint. For a cheerful meal with a variety of reliable options, Sunny Buffet holds steady as a community favorite.
8. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
(631) 620-3688Call
Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc brings a big-city spirit to West Babylon without the price tag. The grill-to-table setup stands out, with cooks preparing stir-fry dishes to your liking right in front of you. I spent time watching as fresh bell peppers and onions sizzled away, and the aromas were worth the visit alone.
The buffet line features well-seasoned grilled chicken and an impressive selection of steamed vegetables. If you’re in the mood for something bold, the spicy tofu is unique and worth a try. The pace here is relaxed, service prompt, and there’s always room for a second—or third—plate. Flaming Grill makes it easy to eat well and feel satisfied.
9. Ruby Buffet Inc
(516) 882-0300Call
Ruby Buffet Inc, tucked inside Sunrise Mall, is a convenient pit stop for hungry shoppers. This buffet’s charm is in its range—there’s something for every craving, and the platters are always refreshed. I dropped by after a marathon shopping run and left marveling at the variety of steamed dumplings and spring rolls.
The lo mein and sautéed green beans are especially popular, each batch arriving hot and flavorful. The self-serve setup makes mixing and matching easy, so your plate is uniquely yours every time. If you want a break from shopping with flavor and flexibility, Ruby Buffet Inc is a safe bet.
10. Creole Buffet
(516) 489-3542Call
Creole Buffet in Uniondale unlocks a palette of flavors you don’t often find in the area. The buffet leans into bold, vegetable-forward dishes and slow-cooked specialties with a Southern twist. My first plate was a mix of seasoned beans and a fluffy cornbread, and each bite offered a kick of spice balanced by a hint of sweetness.
The sautéed collard greens and baked yams are must-try classics. Both reflect the kitchen’s focus on depth and balance, bringing out the heart of Creole cooking. If you’re in the mood for something different from the usual buffet fare, this spot rewards curiosity with rich flavors and genuine comfort.
More Things to Try in Holbrook, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of cuisine can I find at buffets in Holbrook, NY?
You’ll find a good mix, including American comfort food, classic Chinese, fresh salads, grilled veggies, and some restaurants offering Irish, Creole, and global flavors. Each buffet has its own spin, with options for different tastes and dietary needs.
Are buffets in Holbrook family-friendly?
Most buffets in Holbrook welcome families and have seating for groups. Many offer kid-friendly options like mac and cheese, steamed veggies, assorted breads, and fruit, making them a hassle-free choice if you’re dining out with kids.
Do buffets in Holbrook accommodate vegetarians?
Yes, most buffets have a variety of vegetarian options, such as stir-fried vegetables, noodle dishes, salads, and sides. It’s always smart to call ahead if you have strict preferences or allergies.
Is reservation required for popular buffets?
Reservations aren’t usually needed for most buffets, but they can help during busy times, like weekend brunch or big holidays. For larger parties, calling ahead can make things smoother.
Is takeout available from buffets in Holbrook?
Several buffets offer takeout, allowing you to build your own box. Check with each restaurant, since not all locations provide this service.
Are buffets in Holbrook affordable?
Buffets in Holbrook generally range from budget-friendly to moderate in price. Lunch tends to be less expensive than dinner, and there are often discounts for kids and seniors.
