There’s something quietly thrilling about tracking down a great buffet, especially in Holtsville, NY, where options abound but only a few manage to truly impress. I still remember my first local buffet experience: an endless parade of steaming trays, the scent of garlic and ginger mingling in the air, and the comforting realization that seconds (or thirds) weren’t just allowed—they were expected. Each spot seems to have its own personality, whether it’s the springy bite of perfectly cooked noodles or the crunch of fresh vegetables that steal the show.
If you’ve found yourself scrolling through pages of reviews or debating whether that all-you-can-eat spot is actually worth it, you’re in the right place. This guide steers clear of guesswork and shady reheated trays, only serving up reliable, flavor-packed choices where you’ll get your money’s worth. Whether you crave classic Asian dishes, crave-worthy grill fare, or that rare place with something for everyone, the buffets on this list are more than just convenient—they’re destinations. Hungry? Let’s dive into Holtsville’s buffet scene before the best trays are picked clean.
Where to find the best buffets in Holtsville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best buffets in Holtsville, NY:
- Buffet Express
- Old Country Buffet
- Empire Buffet
- Bhr Corp
- Good Taste Buffet
- Sunny Buffet
- Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
- Ruby Buffet Inc
- Creole Buffet
- East West Buffet
1. Buffet Express
(631) 981-8243Call
Buffet Express isn’t fancy, but it’s refreshingly dependable. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by an air of bustle and a generous buffet that invites you to fill your plate. Whenever I’ve visited, I noticed regulars know by heart which trays to hit up first—the stir-fried vegetables and the delicate, fluffy rice always manage to disappear fastest.
Buffet Express stands out for its simple, well-executed dishes and speedy turnover, which means every plate leaves the kitchen fresh. Look for the crispy fried chicken, an unassuming favorite, and the sesame noodles that never seem to linger long under the heat lamps.
If you’re in the mood for something comforting, try the steamed fish and the sautéed greens—both shine with straightforward flavor. Looking for variety and value, it’s the ideal stop for a casual meal that delivers every time.
2. Old Country Buffet
Old Country Buffet conjures up memories of big family meals and plates so full you wonder if you’ll need help back to your seat. Every visit for me has felt a bit like stepping into a comforting reunion—familiar food, warm lighting, and a steady shuffle of diners who never seem rushed.
What always sets Old Country Buffet apart is the variety of hearty, home-style cooking. The mashed potatoes are velvet-smooth, and the roasted vegetables taste like they were just pulled from the garden. If you only grab one thing, make it their baked fish or the classic vegetable medley—each dish lands on the plate with that just-made freshness they’re known for.
There’s always something for everyone, and the reliable quality keeps regulars coming back. For an easy, satisfying meal, it’s a spot you can count on.
3. Empire Buffet
(631) 874-4200Call
Empire Buffet is the sort of place where you can walk in hungry and walk out completely satisfied. During my last visit, the staff was quick to clear plates and keep the buffet lines looking inviting, making the whole experience feel smooth and hassle-free.
Empire Buffet’s real draw is its wide selection and consistent quality across popular Chinese buffet classics. The vegetable lo mein comes perfectly stir-fried, and the steamed broccoli manages to keep its bite—not the soggy stuff you dread. Sweet and tangy stir-fry dishes, especially with tofu and vibrant bell peppers, are always in rotation.
If you have room left, sample their spicy egg drop soup, which never disappoints. With plenty of choices, both fresh and tasty, Empire Buffet is great for anyone craving variety without sacrificing flavor.
4. Bhr Corp
(631) 543-9583Call
Bhr Corp offers an unfussy, laid-back buffet experience that focuses on quality over showiness. When I stopped by, the welcoming vibe and swift service made it easy to settle in and start exploring the options. There’s a steady buzz of diners who clearly know their favorite stations.
Bhr Corp stands out with its well-seasoned sautéed vegetables and fragrant steamed rice, always replenished before you can blink. The mild curry dishes are quietly comforting, not overpowering, and perfect for anyone seeking gentle spice.
The highlight for me is the vegetable stir-fry—crisp, colorful, and bursting with flavor. If you’re searching for a reliable spot that delivers satisfying, flavorful staples, Bhr Corp fits the bill.
5. Good Taste Buffet
(631) 543-9583Call
Good Taste Buffet is the sort of neighborhood spot that feels like a well-kept local secret. Each time I’ve visited, the staff has been welcoming without fuss, and the buffet is always well-stocked, even during lunch rush. There’s excellent value here, especially for families or big groups looking for a quick, no-pressure meal.
The buffet shines thanks to its simple, fresh Chinese dishes and rapid turnover. The vegetable fried rice is fluffy with just enough crunch from mixed veggies. Try the steamed dumplings—pillowy, warm, and clearly made with care.
You’ll find fresh sautéed greens and a selection of gentle stir-fries that are never greasy or heavy. If you enjoy classic flavors and solid portions, Good Taste Buffet is a comforting pick in Commack.
6. Sunny Buffet
(631) 665-6050Call
Sunny Buffet offers an inviting, bright setting—just right for a casual meal with friends or family. When I dropped in, the dining room felt relaxed and the food stations stayed impressively neat, thanks to fast-moving staff.
What sets Sunny Buffet apart is its dedication to freshness and variety on a budget. The sautéed string beans have the perfect snap, and the lo mein nods to old-school Chinese takeout, but without the excess oil. Their vegetable spring rolls are always crisp, never soggy, and disappear the fastest during peak hours.
If you’re in the mood for something light, the steamed broccoli and tofu are reliable choices. Overall, Sunny Buffet is a smart choice for affordable, flavorful bites in Bay Shore.
7. Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc
(631) 620-3688Call
Flaming Grill & Buffet Inc is where quantity meets steady quality, making it a favorite among those who enjoy exploring a crowded buffet line. My visits are usually marked by the lively hum near the grill station, where chefs work fast without missing a beat.
The hot bar overflows with classic Asian-inspired dishes, and you can always count on the grilled-to-order vegetables and stir-fried noodles. Grab a plate of sautéed bok choy or the spiced tofu stir-fry—both are cooked fresh and showcase the kitchen’s attention to flavor.
If you’re in the mood to customize, the grill station lets you build a plate just the way you like. All told, Flaming Grill offers plenty of choice and a lively, welcoming pace for any buffet lover.
8. Ruby Buffet Inc
(516) 882-0300Call
Ruby Buffet Inc is always bustling, thanks in part to its prime location in Sunrise Mall. I’ve stopped in during shopping sprees and found the spot perfect for recharging—plenty of seating, quick turnover, and a steady flow of hot dishes arriving from the kitchen.
What makes Ruby Buffet stand out is the freshness and color on every tray. The vegetable fried rice is always well-seasoned, while the sautéed mushrooms and broccoli remain crisp and full of flavor. Their cold bar, with fresh salads and fruit, provides a nice break between heartier plates.
If you crave something comforting, try the egg drop soup and the simple yet satisfying steamed dumplings. Ruby Buffet delivers consistent quality and a vibrant spread without fuss or pretense.
9. Creole Buffet
(516) 489-3542Call
Creole Buffet brings a distinct Southern flair to the buffet scene in Uniondale. On my last visit, the warm, friendly staff set a welcoming tone, and the lively atmosphere hinted at the bold flavors to come. It’s a place that feels genuine—unpretentious but memorable.
The standouts here are the slow-cooked vegetable stews and the aromatic rice dishes that seem to anchor every plate. The sautéed greens and seasoned yams offer a taste of traditional Creole comfort, while the corn pudding is worth a repeat trip to the hot bar.
Make sure to sample the robust bean dishes and the freshly baked cornbread. At Creole Buffet, the balance of hearty, home-style choices and soulful flavors keeps locals coming back.
10. East West Buffet
(516) 579-3388Call
East West Buffet in Levittown is a reliable choice for diners who crave both variety and value. My visit felt like a world tour on a plate, with flavors that span from classic stir-fry to lighter, veggie-forward options. The flow of the buffet never slows, so there’s almost always something hot and fresh ready to grab.
What sets East West Buffet apart is its blend of Asian and American comfort favorites, all prepared with attention to freshness. The sautéed mixed vegetables are crisp, and their fried rice has that satisfying balance of fluffy grains and savory notes.
Try the vegetable lo mein and finish with a bowl of miso soup for a balanced meal. East West Buffet provides a handy, all-in-one spot for broad tastes and hungry appetites.
More Things to Try in Holtsville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best buffets in Holtsville, NY?
Some top options include Buffet Express, Empire Buffet, and Good Taste Buffet. Each offers a blend of classic dishes, lots of variety, and fresh choices that make them local favorites.
Are there any buffets with vegetarian options in Holtsville?
Yes, most buffets feature a range of vegetarian dishes like sautéed veggies, rice, noodle plates, salads, and soups—especially at Buffet Express and Sunny Buffet.
How much does a buffet usually cost in Holtsville, NY?
Buffet prices vary, but most spots range from $10 to $20 per person depending on timing and selection. Weekends and dinner are usually on the higher end.
Do I need a reservation for buffets in Holtsville?
Most buffets are walk-in friendly and rarely require reservations unless you’re coming with a large group—then a call ahead can help you snag a good table.
Are there buffets suitable for families or large groups?
Absolutely. Places like Old Country Buffet and Flaming Grill & Buffet are spacious and have kid-friendly choices, making them ideal for gatherings of any size.
